‘They refuse to leave’: Homeowner helping daughter’s friends turns into eviction nightmare – fox10tv.com

What began as a simple act of kindness for her daughter’s friends has spiraled into a months-long struggle for one Alabama homeowner, who now faces an unexpected and stressful eviction battle.

Offering a Helping Hand

Earlier this year, Mobile resident Lisa Johnson* opened her doors to two of her daughter’s friends, hoping to help them get back on their feet. “They needed a place to stay, and I thought I could help,” Johnson explained. She allowed the pair to move into her home, believing it would be a temporary arrangement until they found stable housing.

From Guests to Unwanted Tenants

However, what was meant to be a short-term solution has become a drawn-out ordeal. Johnson says the guests have overstayed their welcome—and now refuse to leave. “They just won’t go,” she said. “I never imagined it would come to this.”

The Legal Roadblocks

Johnson soon discovered that removing unwanted occupants isn’t as simple as asking them to leave. According to Alabama law, once someone has established residency—even informally—they may be considered tenants. This means the homeowner must go through a formal eviction process, which can be time-consuming and costly.

• Filing an eviction notice
• Waiting for a court date
• Potential appeals and delays

“It’s incredibly frustrating,” Johnson said. “I tried to help, and now I’m stuck in a legal nightmare.”

Expert Advice for Homeowners

Legal experts warn that situations like Johnson’s are not uncommon. “Once someone has lived in your home for a certain period, even without a lease, they may have rights as tenants,” explained attorney Mark Davis. He recommends that homeowners:

• Set clear boundaries and expectations before allowing anyone to stay
• Put any agreements in writing
• Understand local landlord-tenant laws

“It’s always best to consult with an attorney before taking action,” Davis advised.

Emotional and Financial Toll

For Johnson, the ordeal has taken a significant emotional and financial toll. She worries about the impact on her family and the safety of her home. “I just want my house back,” she said. “I never thought helping someone could turn into this.”

Looking Ahead

As Johnson waits for her court date, she hopes her story will serve as a cautionary tale for others considering opening their homes. “Be careful who you let in,” she warned. “It’s not always easy to get them out.”

*Name has been changed for privacy.